Racial Formation

25 July 2022
4.7 (114 reviews)
17 test answers

Unlock all answers in this set

Unlock answers (13)
question
How do Omi & Winant (2015) define race?
answer
A concept that signifies and symbolizes social conflicts and interests by referring to different types of human bodies
question
According to Omi & Winant (2015), what is racial formation + what are its 3 components?
answer
(1) Sociohistorical process by which racial identities are created, lived out, transformed, + destroyed; (2) racialization, racial projects, + racial politics
question
Provide a definition for each of the 3 components of racial formation theory
answer
(1) Racialization is the process of imparting meaning to previously racially unclassified relationships, practices, or groups; (2) a racial project is simultaneously an interpretation of racial identities/meanings and an effort to organize and distribute resources along racial lines; (3) racial politics (the political structure of race relations; shifted from a racial despotism based on coercion to a racial hegemony based on consent)
question
Provide 3 examples of racial projects
answer
(1) Resistance by White parents to changes in school policies or practices that would limit their children's advantages, justified by appeal to the "ostensive" aspect of organizational routines (Lewis & Diamond 2015); (2) New York state lawsuit in the 1990s alleging minority students in public schools receive lesser expenditures per pupil than White students, and the state's response that the "real" problem is poverty + troubled families (Lopez 2003); (3) the shift in the criterion for citizenship + rights in the early U.S. from property ownership to legal recognition of Whiteness (Harris 1993)
question
Main 3 elements of Feagin's (2010) systemic racism theory
answer
(1) Manifestation of racism across key institutional domains, (2) unjustly gained resources/power of whites, (3) ideologies/attitudes of white supremacy that rationalize the system ("white racial frame")
question
Define Emirbayer & Desmond's (2015) notion of the racial order
answer
The set of racial fields across structural, cultural, and collective-emotional matrices of relations, which organize conflict over the conservation or transformation of relations of domination
question
How do Emirbayer & Desmond's "racial field" extend Bourdieu's concept of the social field?
answer
The social field comprises a structured space of positions determining (and determined by) volume and types of capital possessed by position-holders; racial fields are a kind of social field in which "racial capital" (the capacity to determine the relative value of all resources in a field) operates at nested levels (groups, nations, global system)
question
One example of Emirbayer & Desmond's "races as fields" is the "field of blackness." Describe the structure of this field and its position within the broader racial "field of power" in U.S. society.
answer
(1) 2-D plane with one axis running from low-to-high economic/political power and one from low-to-high black capital, whereby positions high in each form of capital tend to be unstable; (2) in a subordinate position within the "field of power," characterized by a structural antagonism b/t holders of economic/political privilege vs. those w/ educational/cultural preeminence
question
Describe how the racial order can be understood as a space of (1) cultural and (2) collective-emotional relations
answer
(1) Racial fields organize symbolic position-takings (or places within universes of meaning) + (2) affective emotion-takings (or sentiments of attachment/solidarity and hostility/aggression); each are structured according to binary schemes between dominated/dominating poles within "races as fields" and "fields of races"
question
According to Emirbayer & Desmond (2015), what are the 3 modalities of agency actors employ within racial fields?
answer
Dispositional or habitual (routine), the projective (purpose), and the practical evaluative (judgment)
question
What are the 3 components of racialized social systems (RSSs) identified by Bonilla-Silva (1997)?
answer
(1) Hierarchy of racial categories which structures resource allocation + relations b/t groups (thereby shaping their dissimilar interests), (2) the distinct racial character of some conflicts or "racial contestation," (3) "racism" or segment of the ideological structure that crystallizes racial ideas and performs practical functions
question
What are Loveman's (1999) critiques of structural race theory, and how does Bonilla-Silva (1999) respond to each?
answer
(1) Conflating categories w/ groups [but social groups do not need to be conscious of their status in order to exist], (2) reifying race [but fluidity of boundaries does not negate existence nor interests of racial groups b/c, once constructed, real hierarchical relations of opposition emerge], and (3) assuming essential distinction b/t "race" + "ethnicity" [but distinction b/t them is warranted given their unique histories, typical attribution, and relationship to power]
question
Bonilla-Silva (2004) argues a triracial stratification system, comprising "whites," "honorary whites," and "collective blacks," is emerging the contemporary U.S. (1) What evidence does he provide for the emergence of this system + (2) what does he suggest its consequences will be?
answer
(1) Compared w/ their darker-skinned counterparts, lighter-skinned Latinos + Asians are attaining higher SES, more likely to identify as White, and more likely to marry and reside in neighborhoods w/ Whites; (2) race conflict will be buffered by the intermediate group, color gradations within groups will grow in salience, and Americans will begin making nationalist appeals and claiming they are "beyond race"
question
Garroutte (2001) describes how claims to American Indian membership are subject to both tribal and federal government criteria. Provide examples of criteria and consequences of legal recognition for each.
answer
(1) Tribal: blood quantum, descendant of tribal member, residency, community participation, or tribal vote; consequences: rights to participate in tribal politics, cultural life, and/or access to residence on tribal land; (2) gov: blood quantum, residency, land ownership, or tribal citizenship; consequences: economic resource distribution or rights, applicability of legal protections, religious freedoms, and right to market artwork as authentically Indian-made
question
What are Feagin & Elias's (2013) 4 critiques of Omi & Winant's racial formation theory?
answer
(1) Insufficient attention to whites' role in perpetuating racial domination; (2) overemphasis on the ideological dimension of race and the state as a site of racial conflict; (3) assumption of a transition from racial dictatorship based on domination/coercion to racial democracy based on consent/hegemony; and (4) rejection of the black 'radical' tradition and black counter-framing scholarship
question
List and define Roth's (2016) 6 dimensions of race
answer
(1) Racial identity (self-identification), (2) racial self-classification (category chosen among a limited set of options), (3) observed race (race others believe you to be), (4) reflected race (an individual's belief of how others classify them), (5) phenotype (aspects of a person's physical appearance socially understood as relevant to racial classification), and (6) ancestry (known or genetic)
question
Roth (2016) argues the multidimensionality of race should be distinguished from which 2 related but distinct concepts?
answer
(1) Racial fluidity, or fluctuation within one dimension over time or across contexts; and (2) racial boundaries, which can be "bright" or "blurred" but only change over longer periods of time than most dynamism in dimensionality or fluidity is observed